Thank God for ‘Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star’
July 21st, 2008 | Filed under Conversations, Friends, History, Humour, Public Affairs, Trivia
A few months ago, I was teaching my 4-year old nephew some nursery rhymes with a DVD. After a lot of singing, he slowly digested the story that the rhymes tell. And then he began asking rather uncomfortable questions. One of the first rhymes I taught him was Humpty Dumpty.
Humpty Dumpty sat on a wall,
Humpty Dumpty had a great fall.
All the King’s horses, And all the King’s men
Couldn’t put Humpty together again!
He might have finally understood the rhyme when he gasped and said curiously, “Did he die?”
“Well,” I replied, “he’s an egg. Who cares?”
“I like eggs. Did they cook Humpty Dumpty?”
“Maybe. Who knows?” He looked sorry but we went on singing. And then there was Rock-A-Bye Baby.
Rock a bye baby on the tree top,
When the wind blows the cradle will rock,
When the bough breaks the cradle will fall,
And down will come baby, cradle and all.
And again, my nephew asked, “Tito, did the baby die?”
“I hope not. But it was just a baby and it fell from a tree. So… Poor baby.”
“Why was the baby on top of the tree?”
“I dunno. Maybe it was a baby koala bear,” I dodged, not realising that a-koala-cub-in-a-cradle was a very stupid thought. But really, my nephew was right, why the hell is the baby on the tree top, anyway?
I went on teaching him more nursery rhymes. Itsy Bitsy Spider. Pop Goes the Weasel. Peter Peter Pumpkin-eater. Old King Cole. Baa Baa Black Sheep.
I’ve always noticed that many of our nursery rhymes are actually very violent. I don’t usually give a damn. But my nephew was smart enough to understand what he was singing and sensitive enough to actually feel for the characters. After almost every rhyme I taught him, he would ask me what happened to the character.
- to Peter’s wife whom he kept inside a pumpkin. (Peter Peter Pumpkin-eater)
- to the itsy-bitsy spider after going up the spout again (Itsy Bitsy Spider)
- to the three blind mice after the farmer’s wife cut off their tails (Three Blind Mice)
- to the four and twenty blackbirds that were baked in a pie (Sing a Song of Sixpence)
- to Jack who fell down and to Jill who tumbled after (Jack and Jill)
I had to remind my nephew that it was bad to make fun of blind people (or blind mice, for that matter) and that pies don’t have dead black birds in them (at least, not usually). And guess what my nephew said after Jack and Jill. “Tito, did they die?”
Thank God he didn’t ask how many people were killed when the London Bridge fell down.
But even before this incident, I’ve always been wondering why these nursery rhymes have a sort of violent theme. Glenn once told me that they reflect history — what was happening at the time of the rhyme’s creation. It was only five minutes ago when I did some research and this is what I have found.










